Skip to Content

16 Delicious Cream Pie Recipes

Cream pies are my favorite type of pie. This collection is brought to you by All opinions are my own. Since March 14th is pie day, it’s the perfect time to share this cream pie collection with you.

16 Delicious Cream Pie Recipes

Did I ever mention that I worked as a waitress at Baker’s Square for about 5 years? I had a blast working there and definitely had my fair share of pie-tasting. I quickly learned that my favorites all contained whipped cream. Anything with chocolate, peanut butter, cream cheese and whipped cream was pretty much irresistible to me. We categorized all the pies as either “cream pies” or “fruit pies”, and I could eat the heck out of the cream pies. In fact, it was a tad bit dangerous to work there with my sweet tooth!

Now that I have been starting to experiment more in the kitchen, I am anxious to try making some cream pies on my own. There are so many delicious recipes out there and several seem a lot easier than I would have anticipated.

16 Delicious Cream Pie Recipes

It’s safe to say that we will be celebrating pie day on March 14th. I mean, who am I to ignore such an important day? 😉 We shall celebrate it to the fullest with at least one slice of a delicious cream pie.

Here’s another scrumptious tip: Create a pie shake by tossing a piece of pie into the blender with a scoop of ice cream and some milk. Oh my goodness is that an indulgent treat!

Just look at the Turtle Pie from Edwards — Oh my gosh!

What is your favorite type of pie? Do you like cream pies or fruit pies better?

Jessica Lodge

Sunday 6th of April 2014

I haven't had too many cream pies in my lifetime, I grew up in WA so we always had apple pie when we had pie. My favorite pie is pumpkin(not sure what category that falls under).

Julie Wood

Thursday 3rd of April 2014

I love Cream Pies! They are so delicious and there are so many here that I want to try to make this Spring and Summer. I like to make the cold cream pies, such as Chocolate or Banana Cream!


Saturday 29th of March 2014

YUM! The salted caramel brownie cheesecake especially sounds to die for! And a pie shake sounds really good.

Jennifer Hiles

Friday 28th of March 2014

I'm a big fan of cream pies myself. I'm not sure if it's the filling or the crust that I don't like. I'm thinking crust because I always prefer graham cracker crusts. I used to work at a diner that made the most amazing pb pie!!

Sarah L

Tuesday 11th of March 2014

I want to try the Snickerdoodle pie first, then all the others. Wonderful recipes.

Comments are closed.