Skip to Content

Beware of this Screamsicle Mini Milkshakes Recipe

Looking for a hauntingly delicious Halloween treat? There are so many possibilities using TruMoo. With all of their tasty flavors, you really can’t go wrong. This was our first time trying the TruMoo Orange Scream flavor and it’s frighteningly scrumptious!

Beware of this Screamsicle Mini Milkshakes Recipe

I bought some jelly jars with the intention of making us mini milkshakes. Mike and I both love milkshakes, but there’s no reason to drink enormous ones on a daily basis. Mini milkshakes are just enough and make the perfect dessert. Obviously, they are an ideal size for kids, too.

Beware of this Screamsicle Mini Milkshakes Recipe

When I brought home the Orange Scream it was a challenge to keep Mike away from it. I purposely bought some TruMoo Chocolate milk, too, to try to keep him away from the tempting new flavor. Of course, it’s delicious on its own, but I wanted to make a recipe with it. visit their website for more delicious TruMoo Halloween recipes

For fun mini milkshakes just in time for Halloween, I made this Screamsicle recipe. It’s not difficult at all and you can definitely add your own twists to make it unique.

Screamsicle Mini Milkshakes Recipe


  • TruMoo Orange Scream Milk
  • French vanilla ice cream
  • Whipped cream
  • Strawberry syrup
  • Spooky toppings


Blend ice cream and milk and pour into tiny jars or glasses. You can pour a little of the red syrup down the jar for a “bloody” look, as well. Top with whipped cream and syrup. Add whichever spooky toppings you like. We used gummy worms and Halloween-themed chips.

Beware of this Screamsicle Mini Milkshakes Recipe

The flavor is scary good and tastes like a dreamsicle. Don’t tell anyone but I had two mini milkshakes all to myself. There goes my mini milkshake portion control theory. They are just too tasty!

TruMoo starts with fresh, pure milk from a trusted dairy. It contains 8 essential nutrients and is sweetened with just enough sugar. It contains NO high fructose corn syrup, NO artificial growth hormones and NO HFCS. What it does have is the flavors that kids love!

If you like frozen drink, try these next:

Learn more about the great flavors on Facebook and definitely follow their Pinterest page for lots of great recipes!


Sunday 16th of November 2014

I still have not tried TruMoo Milk yet, this yummy treat would be the perfect recipe to try it in. I'd like to make this treat with chocolate milk instead of the Orange. Thank you for sharing this recipe.

Autumn @MamaChallenge

Thursday 23rd of October 2014

The perfect Halloween treat. I tried to find them at my WaLMART AND THEY WEREN'T THERE SO I'll have to dig around bc we want some:)

Kristin Wheeler (@MamaLuvsBooks)

Wednesday 22nd of October 2014

These look SO SUPER YUMMY! My kids would LOVE them!!! Pinning!


Wednesday 22nd of October 2014

I purchased the Orange milk the other day just because of your post! It is really good!


Wednesday 22nd of October 2014

We just bought this! We were strolling by and the kiddo saw the orange milk and well... yeah. I NEED that he said. It's really quite good!