Skip to Content

Fairy Toadstool Recipe

Perhaps Pinterest brought you to this fairy toadstool recipe post. Your usual Pin-for-later behavior–in which later means never, altered because this recipe actually looks doable. So, you clicked.

If that’s the case, welcome and thank you for visiting! Your instincts have proven correct.

Tasty Toadstools in 20 Minutes

This adorable recipe is super easy and can be ready in just 20 minutes!

These whimsical little treats are sure to put a smile on even the grouchiest face.

Whip them up for themed parties, showers, sleepover extravaganzas, or just as a surprise after school snack.

Pair them with our magical toadstool cupcakes!

Fairy toadstools and fox on plate

You’ll want to serve them immediately because the donuts dry out relatively quickly. However, you could coat them in frosting to lock in the moisture.

That step will add to your prep time and increase the sugar and calorie content but could be worth it depending on your needs.

Donut holes and Tootsie Rolls - Fairy Toadstool treats

Experiment with different colored frostings, sprinkles, donut hole flavors, and edible glitters to create a magical grove of toadstools.

Easy Fairy Toadstool Recipe

Fairy toadstool recipe steps
Yield: 12 toadstools

Fairy Toadstool Treats

Donut holes and Tootsie Rolls - Fairy Toadstool treats

Gnomes, fairies, and all woodland creatures are welcome at this party! These fairy toadstool treats are super easy to make and are sure to please a crowd.

Prep Time 20 minutes
Total Time 20 minutes

Ingredients

  • 12 plain donut holes
  • 24 Tootsie Rolls
  • Red Wilton Sparkle Gel
  • Orange Wilton Sparkle Gel
  • Yellow Wilton Sparkle Gel
  • Light green Wilton Sparkle Gel
  • Dark green Wilton Sparkle Gel
  • Coconut Grass
  • 1/2 cup coconut
  • 1 tsp water
  • green food coloring
  • resealable plastic bag

Instructions

  1. Cut donut holes in half with a bread knife. 
  2. Unwrap, but do not remove, Tootsie Rolls.
  3. Place 3 at a time in the microwave and microwave for 5 seconds.
  4. Discard wrappers and shape Tootsie Rolls into a mushroom stem.
  5. Set on a flat surface to harden.
  6. Gently press donut hole halves into each stem.
  7. Decorate with color gels. TIP: The trick is to use a little color gel, not a lot, otherwise it will run down the donut.

Coconut Grass Garnish

  1. Place coconut into a resealable sandwich bag. 
  2. Add 1 teaspoon of water to a small bowl. Add 4 drops green food coloring and mix well.
  3. Add to coconut.
  4. Seal bag and knead until color is evenly distributed through coconut.
  5. Place toadstools onto a plate and add coconut grass/moss. Serve immediately.

Notes

You'll want to serve these pretty quickly as the donut holes will dry out. 

Please note that these nutrition facts are an estimate based on similar ingredients. To calculate this approximation, cupcakes were used in place of donut holes.

Recommended Products

As an Amazon Associate and member of other affiliate programs, I earn from qualifying purchases.

Nutrition Information:

Yield:

12

Serving Size:

1 toadstool

Amount Per Serving: Calories: 130Total Fat: 6gSaturated Fat: 4gTrans Fat: 0gUnsaturated Fat: 2gCholesterol: 4mgSodium: 74mgCarbohydrates: 18gFiber: 2gSugar: 11gProtein: 1g

Nutrition facts are an estimate only.

Did you make this recipe?

I'd love to see your recreation. Tag me in your photos!

Donut holes and Tootsie Rolls - Fairy Toadstool treats

For every donut hole, you’ll want two Tootsie Rolls. So, if you need 50 toadstools, get 25 donut holes and 50 Tootsie Rolls.

Donut holes and Tootsie Rolls - Fairy Toadstool treats
Tootsies frooties
$20.72 ($0.26 / Ounce)
Buy Now
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
10/15/2021 04:06 am GMT

Other Magical Ideas

  • Try using Tootsie Fruit Chews for the stems to add fruity flavors and rainbow colors to your yummy woodland display.
  • Decorate gummy worms to look like caterpillars and stage them atop the toadstools for an Alice in Wonderland theme.
  • Create a garden of chaos with these recipes for unicorn bark, unicorn crackers, and unicorn poop cookies.
  • If you end up with an excess of donut holes, check out this recipe for unicorn donut holes!
  • Go the Super Mario route and make these power-ups for the littles.
  • Don’t forget the props. We love these fun trees, pretty fairies, unicorns, and yoga gnomes–yes, yoga gnomes.
Donut holes and Tootsie Rolls - Fairy Toadstool treats

Pin to save and share!

Woodland fairy Toadstool treats

Make these fairy toadstools and let us know what you did to make them unique!

We’d love to see them on Instagram, Facebook, or Twitter! Tag us!

Lily Kwan

Saturday 6th of April 2019

This recipe looks very cute and tasty. Thanks for sharing!

Buddy Garrett

Saturday 6th of April 2019

I love this recipe. The Fairy Toadstools would be great for a school party.

Stephanie Grant

Saturday 6th of April 2019

These look like so much fun! I think the kiddos would really enjoy them for our fairy party!

charlotte

Saturday 6th of April 2019

Thank you for the super cute ideas, I can't wait to try them out!

amber kolb

Saturday 6th of April 2019

These treats are so unique and fun! I think this would be really cute for a party. I love your nail polish too!

Comments are closed.
Skip to Recipe