Skip to Content

Delicious and Enchanting Woodland Fairy Toadstool Trifle Recipe

Magical people of the land, it’s time to gather. I’m beyond excited to present to you this enchanting woodland fairy toadstool recipe! This adorable and whimsical little fairy garden is completely edible and ready to wow the guests of your next celebration. This post contains affiliate links.

With layers of creamy chocolate pudding, whipped topping, fluffy cake, and crunchy cookies, this trifle is as delicious as it gets. But, the real magic comes from the adorable toadstool mushrooms on the top of the trifle. With red and white cookie caps and wafer stems, they are as fun to eat as they are to look at.

Woodland fairy trifle with cookies that look like toadstools on top.

Magical Fairy Mushroom Trifle

The woodland fairy theme is one of my absolute favorites. It’s fitting for any kind of celebration at all. You can make it work for little kid birthday parties, whimsical wedding showers, and so much more. Creating desserts for a fairy garden party is the perfect opportunity to unleash your creativity.

Don’t let the details of this magical mushroom trifle intimidate you. Take it step by step, and you will see how easy it is to create an edible fairy garden of your own. If you just want the delicious layers, feel free to make an easy chocolate trifle recipe.

Things to Love about this Dessert

Here are a few reasons to fall in love with this fairy toadstool trifle.

  • Unique: The toadstools and enchanted forest look of the top of this trifle is surely something people don’t see every day.
  • Delicious: Even without the magical topping, the layers of pudding, whipped cream, cookies, and cake are a winning flavor combo loved by most. In fact, simply leave the top off for a chocolate Oreo trifle.
  • Customizable: Use your imagination to customize your fairy toadstool realm. Add details to fit an additional theme, decorate it for the holidays, or make all the toadstools different colors. The options are endless!
  • Whimsical: A fairy garden trifle is an easy way to add some whimsy to your dessert table. The colorful toadstools and flower details are sure to draw the eye of people of all ages.
Cookies and other ingredients for the mushroom trifle.

Enchanted Fairy Garden Trifle Ingredients

Here’s what you need to make this magical trifle recipe. The measurements are in the recipe card below.

  • Chocolate cake round – baked and cooled
  • Instant chocolate pudding
  • Milk
  • Whipped topping
  • Chocolate sandwich cookies
  • Vanilla sandwich cookies
  • Green food coloring
  • Fudge-dipped peanut butter cookies
  • Cream-filled wafers
  • Red frosting
  • Mini chocolate chips
  • White candy melts
  • Candy rocks
  • Flower icing decorations

Fairy Toadstool Trifle Directions

Make the chocolate pudding by whisking the milk and pudding mix together for at least 2 minutes. Refrigerate it for at least 5 minutes or until firm.

Mixing chocolate pudding in a container.

Use a food processor to finely crush 15 chocolate sandwich cookies and set them aside. This is for the “dirt” topping, so you want the consistency to be fine.

Chunks of OREO cookies in a bowl.

Break apart the rest of the chocolate sandwich cookies into chunks. This is for the cookie layer of the trifle, so they just need to be bite-sized.

Finely crushed vanilla cookies in a bowl.

To make the “moss,” finely crush the vanilla sandwich cookies into fine crumbs. Place them into a resealable sandwich bag.

Crushed cookies and green food coloring in a sandwich bag.

Add 1/2 teaspoon of water and several drops of green food coloring to the cookie crumbs. Seal the bag and knead it until the mixture is the desired shade of green.

Note: This moss mixture ends up a bit wet. If you don’t like that texture, feel free to make the moss the day before to let it sit and dry a bit.

Cookies and wafers on a board.

To make the toadstool mushrooms, place the chocolate-covered peanut butter cookies onto a flat surface, face down.

Melt the mini chocolate chips in a sandwich bag in the microwave at 50% power for 30 seconds. Knead the chocolate in the bag, and repeat the process until it’s fully melted, about 2 minutes total.

Cut a small tip into the corner of the bag and pipe some melted chocolate onto the center of a cookie.

Placing wafers onto cookies to make toadstools.

Carefully place a full-sized wafer (don’t cut) onto the chocolate and hold it until it’s set. Repeat with each cookie until you have the desired amount of mushrooms. Let them stand to let the chocolate harden completely.

Note: Do not cut the wafers as shown above. It’s best to keep them long. The toadstool is a lot more stable when it is inserted deeper into the trifle layers.

Frosting a cookie with red frosting.

Once the chocolate hardens and the wafers feel securely attached to the cookies, use the red frosting to cover the tops.

Red frosting on an edible toadstool.

Let the toadstools stand. Filling a cup or a bowl with sugar is a great way to keep them steady until you are ready to assemble the trifle.

Edible toadstool in a cup filled with sugar.

Sprinkle the frosted toadstools with crushed white candy melts. You can do this now, or wait until you are topping the trifle.

Crushed white candy melts in a bowl.
Chocolate cake in a trifle dish.

Slice your chocolate cake round in half to create two rounds. Place one of the rounds into your trifle dish.

Chocolate pudding in a trifle bowl.

Top the cake with half of the chocolate pudding.

Whipped cream in a trifle dish.

Follow up with half of the whipped topping.

Chunks of chocolate sandwich cookies in a trifle bowl.

For the next layer, sprinkle on the crushed chocolate sandwich cookies.

Finely crushed chocolate cookies on top of whipped cream.

Repeat each layer, ending with a layer of cookies, but use the finely crushed OREOs that you created earlier.

Cookie toadstool in a trifle.

To decorate the top, place some piles or mounds of the finely crushed chocolate cookies throughout. These are like little piles of dirt to hold the toadstool cookies.

Candy rocks, edible moss, and cookie mushrooms on a trifle.

Push the toadstool mushrooms into the trifle, add the candy rocks, the candy flowers, and pieces of the green “moss” to decorate the top.

Edible rocks, flowers, and toadstools on top of a trifle.

Decorate the top however you like. This is the fun part so get creative with it!

Fairy toadstool trifle in a bowl.

It’s best to serve this trifle right away. If you need to refrigerate for later, be sure to loosely cover it first.

Fairy garden trifle with cookie toadstools, candy rocks, and edible moss.

Serves 12-14 people.

Woodland fairy trifle with edible flowers, moss, and toadstools.

What Else to Serve at your Woodland Fairy Party

If you’re looking to load up the dessert table at a fairy party, here are some more suggestions:

Donut holes and Tootsie Rolls - Fairy Toadstool treats

Fairy toadstool donut holes are very easy to make and a cute addition to the fairy treats.

Magical toadstool cupcakes keep the mushroom theme going. They also look like Super Mario Bros mushrooms or Smurf toadstools, so they work for gamer parties or a Smurfs theme.

Magical Fairy Toadstool Cupcakes
Magical fairy door cookie recipe

Enchanted door cookies are cute, and you can probably even add these to the top of the trifle!

Fairy cupcakes with wings add a little princess vibe to the party.

Fairy wing cupcakes on a little cake stand.
A plate of colorfully glazed mini donuts with sprinkles.

Sprinkle in some glazed mini donuts to add even more color and sprinkly goodness.

Toadstool Trifle Recipe Swaps and Variations

Here are a few suggestions for swaps and tweaks.

  • Cake: If you don’t want to bake a chocolate cake, you can buy one from the bakery or your local grocery store. If it’s not a round cake, simply break up pieces to add to the trifle.
  • Flavors: You can use any type of cake and cookies in this recipe. Chocolate cookies and cake are used here to look like “dirt” for the garden. Since this is a magical land, make it any color and flavor of your dreams!
  • Cookies: If you can’t find chocolate covered peanut butter cookies, just try to find another cookie with a similar shape. You want something with a slightly rounded top for that toadstool look.
  • Frosting: Red frosting is easy to find during the holiday season, but you can easily color your own if you need to. Make or buy white frosting and color it with red food coloring.
Top of a woodland mushroom trifle with cookie toadstools.

Kitchen Tools Needed

Here is a list of equipment that you will need to make this woodland fairy toadstool trifle recipe:

  • 8″ round cake pan: If you plan to bake the cake, you will need an 8″ round cake pan and other basic tools like measuring cups and spoons.
  • Whisk or hand mixer: For baking the cake and whisking the pudding.
  • Food processor: For finely crushing the chocolate cookies to create a “dirt” consistency for the top of the fairy garden trifle.
  • Ziploc bags: Used for coloring the cookie crumbs for moss and for piping on the melted chocolate.
  • Microwave-safe bowl or small saucepan: To melt the chocolate chips.
  • Trifle dish: You can use any kind of bowl or container, but a nice trifle bowl displays it best.
Trifle Bowl
$34.94

Make those trifles look fancy even though they are impossibly easy to make! Display all the layers in this gorgeous trifle bowl.

Buy from Amazon Buy from Walmart
We earn a commission if you click this link and make a purchase at no additional cost to you.
02/04/2023 09:43 am GMT

How to Store Leftovers

Store any woodland toadstool trifle leftovers in an airtight container in the refrigerator. It should last for 2-3 days.

Cookie toadstools sticking out of an Oreo cookie trifle.

Fairy Garden Trifle Recipe Notes and FAQ

Can I make this trifle the day before?

The trifle is best if it’s assembled right before serving, but you can get most of the ingredients ready for the layers. Make the cake, pudding, crush the cookies, color the moss, and have it all ready to go to add to the bowl. Making the “moss” the day before is ideal, so it can dry out a little.

Should I cut the Pirouline wafers?

No, some of the wafers were cut here, but we found it’s best to leave them long. The toadstools are more stable if the stem can stick deep into the trifle layers.

Can I add birthday candles to the top of the trifle?

If you are making this trifle for a birthday party, please note that when the birthday person blows out the candles, the Oreo cookie “dirt” may go flying. It doesn’t hurt the trifle, but it does make a little mess!

Yield: 14

Enchanted Fairy Garden Trifle Recipe

Woodland fairy trifle with cookies that look like toadstools on top.

A magical fairy garden in the form of a delicious trifle. Everything is edible, but it looks like an enchanted fairy garden. Enjoy the rich Oreo cookie flavor combined with creamy pudding and whipped cream. So good!

Prep Time 30 minutes
Total Time 30 minutes

Ingredients

  • 1, 8" round cake, baked and cooled completely
  • 1 package, 3.4 oz, instant chocolate pudding
  • 2 cups milk
  • 1 tub, 8 oz, whipped topping, thawed
  • 30 chocolate sandwich cookies, divided
  • 6 vanilla sandwich cookies
  • green food coloring
  • peanut butter cookies dipped in fudge
  • cream filled wafers (Pirouline)
  • red frosting
  • 2 tablespoons mini chocolate chips
  • 6-8 white candy melts, crushed
  • candy rocks
  • flower icing decorations

Instructions

  1. Mix together pudding and milk and whisk for 2 minutes. Refrigerate for 5 minutes until firm. 
  2. Finely crush 15 chocolate sandwich cookies with a food processor and set aside. Coarsely crush, or break apart the remaining 15 chocolate cookies. Set aside. 
  3. Place vanilla cookies into a food processor and process until fine crumbs. Place into a resealable sandwich bag. Add 1/2 teaspoon water and lots of green food coloring. Seal the bag and knead until the cookies are green. 
  4. To make mushrooms, place peanut butter chocolate covered cookies onto a flat surface, face down. Place mini chocolate chips into a resealable bag but do not seal. Microwave on 50% power for 30 seconds and knead the chocolate. Repeat until the chocolate is completely melted, about 2 minutes total. Cut a small tip into the corner of the bag and pipe onto the center of the cookie. Carefully place a wafer onto the chocolate and hold until set. Repeat until you have the desired number of mushrooms. Let stand for chocolate to harden completely. 
  5. Once chocolate is hard and stems are attached, use red frosting to cover the tops. Sprinkle with crushed white candy melts. Let stand, ideally in a bowl, or a cup filled with sugar, until ready to assemble. 
  6. Slice round cake in half, creating 2 rounds. Place one round into the trifle dish and top with half of the pudding, half of the whipped topping and the crushed chocolate cookies. Repeat layers, ending with a layer of finely crushed chocolate cookies. 
  7. To assemble the top, place some "piles or mounds" of finely crushed cookies in places. Push mushrooms into the trifle, add candy rocks, and candy flowers as well as green moss to decorate and complete the top. 
  8. Serve immediately or refrigerate, loosely covered until ready to serve. 

Notes

The "moss" ends up a bit wet. If you think that texture will bother you, make it the day before to let it sit out and dry.

Leave the wafer "stems" long. Do not cut the wafers in half, so more can stick into the layers.

Nutrition Information:

Yield:

14

Serving Size:

1

Amount Per Serving: Calories: 429Total Fat: 21gSaturated Fat: 10gTrans Fat: 0gUnsaturated Fat: 10gCholesterol: 40mgSodium: 234mgCarbohydrates: 56gFiber: 1gSugar: 41gProtein: 5g

Nutrition facts are an estimate only.

Did you pin this recipe?

Please save a photo to your Pinterest boards!

More Trifle Dessert Recipes

Pin this image to your dessert board to save and share!

Fairy garden trifle dessert with cookie toadstools on top.

If you enjoy whimsical recipes like this one, please subscribe to the blog. Receive magical recipes and more in your inbox.

Please share this fairy toadstool trifle recipe with your friends and family, and let me know if you make it!

Skip to Recipe